Network
Origins of the network
This is a story about the Why? and the What for? of the BetaCodex Network
-
Late 1997
What lies beyond budgeting?
Three Englishmen are trying to solve a problem: Their quest is to discover what’s to be found in that realm of organizational leadership “beyond budgeting“. That quest arose from a simple observation: Most organizations at the time are doing budgeting and planning at least annually, but they are not getting anything out of it. To anyone questioning the prevailing planning practices thoroughly, it is obvious that “managing by budgets” did not make any sense at all in a dynamic and complex world. So our three Englishmen think there has to be an alternative to all this managing by budgets and through “command and control”. There just has to be some better solution to management, a much better place “beyond budgeting”. There surely has to be some existing practice or model that will enable organizations everywhere to get rid of damaging or obsolete rituals like budgeting – and the command-and-control bureaucracy associated with it.
-
Jan 1999
A “beyond budgeting” community
The three Britons set off to gather knowledge and insights, confident that this beyond budgeting research project would sooner or later lead them to a coherent solution. The three Englishmen are Robin Fraser, Jeremy Hope and Peter Bunce. Within an industrial consortium called CAM-I, they are creating a community of corporate “sponsors“. The membership fees will finance the research they will conduct by visiting the case companies and write case studies, to share with the members. The community will soon become known as BBRT, or Beyond Budgeting Round Table. And thus the BBRT sets out to find organizations that aren’t doing budgeting and that are solving managerial problems in rather different and “unusual” ways. At this point, few people in the world believe that management beyond budgeting is possible. But soon, the three Britons indeed stumble upon quite a few exceptional companies which were willing to share their experiences. Those were firms like Handelsbanken, AES, and Borealis.
-
1999 – 2003
Beyond Budgeting case research
The riddle is slowly being solved, over the course of six years. It takes a while, but the case research, the thought process and presentations to the members over time are adding up to a real solution that’s slowly gaining traction under the name Beyond Budgeting model, especially within the accounting, finance and performance management communities. In other words, knowledge about the solution to the problem of planning-based management is accumulated and the problem solved, over time.
A Harvard Business Review article about the Beyond Budgeting model is published in 2003, and the first two books about the model are being published in late 2003, one by Robin Fraser and Jeremy Hope, the other by Niels Pflaeging, who had joined the BBRT as a director, in 2003, and would later co-found the BetaCodex Network.
-
2004 – 2006
The Beyond Budgeting model
It becomes apparent to the research directors that the problem of “figuring out the alternative to command-and-control management” is solved, by and large. It is quite clear now how to get rid of budgeting, planning and centralized steering, for good. The original mission of the BBRT is fulfilled, which none of the directors had quite expected to be happening. But it becomes undeniable. There is indeed a whole world out there, beyond budgeting: With cases and practices, principles and patterns ready to be adopted. The model, or solution makes complete sense, it is coherent in itself and adding up with what other sciences are postulating. Niels Pflaeging publishes an award-winning book on Beyond Budgeting, in 2006. The Beyond Budgeting solution clearly promises exceptional and holistic performance in a competitive world, as the cases prove. This is not the end of the story, of course.
-
2004 – 2005
The quest for transformation
Organizations somewhat admire the Beyond Budgeting solution, but they don’t manage to adopt it. Or at least not as enthusiastically as everyone had expected when the BBRT set off, in 1998. In spite of the insight around the solution, and much recognition, organizations clearly aren’t able to make use of the solution’s potential. “Too radical”, many of them keep saying. Why doesn’t everybody take the solution and go with it? Robin Fraser is the first in the directors team to grasp the problem. He reckons that the solution to the first problem alone wouldn’t do it. All right, the model’s rationale is irrefutable; the BBRT´s insights and conclusions are all correct; the cases prove the point. But how would the CEO of a company approach an enormous change such as “management model transformation, towards Beyond Budgeting”, in practice? The model alone would be sufficient to drive such a profound change process. Nor would the promise alone help change enthusiasts to challenge existing structures and practices. The Beyond Budgeting model alone wouldn’t enable real-world organizations with their real-world management models – although visibly obsolete – to make the change happen.
Robin Fraser, the director in the movement with most experience in consulting, recognizes in 2004 that there are a lot of good ideas out there about how to create change in general, but not much experience around something quite as big as transforming complete management models in earnest. There isn’t much experience about transformation available from the BBRT’s case companies either, because those few organizations which had undertaken it in the 70s or 80s hadn’t thoroughly documented the process. In addition, not many people out there believe that transformation could be done in the absence of a super-hero-like CEO or company owner. Not even in the BBRT itself the belief in the possibility of transformation is sufficiently wide-spread. Robin, however, is firmly convinced in that the second challenge is what matters now.
So Robin and Niels intensify working on tools and concepts to make transformation happen. Robin makes a bold and promising attempt in 2004 and 2005 with a consulting client, a company from Italy, to bring about full-fledged transformation. But it doesn’t yet quite happen. And there’s an additional challenge. While the problem of the Beyond Budgeting model had been about research derived from cases and science, the transformation riddle will be more about actually practicing transformation and deriving conclusions from that consulting work. It requires what Kurt Lewin had once coined “action research.” While the first stage of research required understanding the nuts and bolts of a new management model in theory, the second is about understanding the nuts and bolts of people changing their organizations, their companies. This work would be far more “practical”, requiring more diverse skills and a more diverse team. And individuals willing to take huge perceived risks and go for transformation anyway. So what does all that mean for the network and the international membership?
-
2007
BBRT crisis
The BBRT community goes into crisis. Some members of the BBRT community approached the transformation, even without a clear approach to transformation in sight, each of them in their own fashion, but they either hadn’t gotten very far, or the changes wouldn’t stick. Some organizations had outright failed to implement the solution earlier, some thought they had managed to pull off transformation, only to experience a backlash later-on. Most in the community aren’t daring to try implementation, however even after years of membership. They hesitate because implementation seems too big a challenge. So the BBRT faces another fog, a new problem. It becomes clear to Robin Fraser and Niels Pflaeging that there simply is another problem that needs solving, which was hidden behind the first. And that second problem requires an entirely different solution.
Among the research directors, discussions around the mission and research direction emerge. On one hand, the insights gathered since 1998 are shared with more and more members, and also publicly. There is wide-spread recognition of the Beyond Budgeting model now – and not rarely applause, and opposition by entrenched groups of interest. On the other hand, it is not clear to the BBRT’s directors what should come next. The group of directors is torn: Some favor continuing as usual, and keep talking about the Beyond Budgeting model to members. Robin and Niels favor going after transformation, in order to keep learning about both the model and its adoption. In late 2007, at a meeting of BBRT directors in Switzerland, the split between the two factions becomes apparent, and the split becomes inevitable.
-
2008
Foundation of the BetaCodex Network
In early 2008, the BetaCodex Network is founded. It understands itself as the BBRT's logical continuation, but it is different from the BBRT, in several ways. As understanding of the emerging new model has become wide-spread, the BetaCodex assumes that it is the time for organizations around the world, regardless of their size, industry or location, to make the principles of the BetaCodex real. The commitment of the BetaCodex Network is to continue the BBRT's work in a way that is consistent with the need for practical transformation, by researching transformation and the model. The BetaCodex Network's vision is: “The BetaCodex is the standard codex for organizations.” Transformation, in consequence, is for everyone.
Even though the BetaCodex Network and the BBRT (now “Beyond Budgeting Institute”) are intimately connected through the belief in similar principles, there are significant differences between the two movements. For instance, the BetaCodex Network is more open, collaborative and inclusive than the previous effort, in order to significantly increase the speed of model and method development, deployment and shared learning. This is not just an option, but a necessity, as the BetaCodex Network is achieving its vision not through mere research but through transformation work in the real world. Organizations starting transformation need solutions for their real-life problems, and they cannot wait infinitely. The amount of practical innovation needed for transformation over the course of the next years will be immense.
As a consequence, and firstly, the BetaCodex Network has to be “open source”, which means that everyone in the world will be able to contribute to the network’s work (much like Wikipedia). Being truly open source, we believe, will enable the network to capture far more talent and innovative potential than before. Open source also means that everyone in the world can gain access to the full intellectual capital of the network. And that intense collaboration will happen through web portals and social media platforms. Secondly, the BetaCodex Network is strictly non-commercial. Eventual income will be exclusively dedicated to finance joint infrastructure, or the network's projects, such as this website, and web-based tools, or special membership activities. Income, when it occurs, will not be used for anyone's personal gain, or income generation.
"The BetaCodex is the standard codex for organizations."
What happened next: The first 19 years of the network →